Windows pin is no longer available

by

Summary

Key takeaway: A hardware upgrade (especially motherboard or TPM change) broke Windows Hello PIN trust, and manual removal of credential files left the system in an unrecoverable lockscreen state because Windows relies on secure, hardware-bound containers that cannot simply be deleted without breaking the login flow.

Root Cause

  • Hardware ID Mismatch: Windows Hello binds the PIN to a unique machine ID (often derived from TPM, SMBIOS, or a hardware fingerprint). Swapping the motherboard or major components changes this ID, invalidating the stored PIN secrets.
  • NGC Container Integrity: The %SystemRoot%\ServiceProfiles\LocalService\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Ngc folder contains encrypted PIN secrets. If these are missing/corrupted (or the key is lost after hardware change), the PIN becomes “no longer available due to security reasons.”
  • Broken Sign-in Stack State: Removing password via net user or other commands without properly resetting Windows Hello leaves the sign-in stack expecting a PIN but with no valid container or fallback method.

Why This Happens in Real Systems

  • Secure Enrollment Model: Windows Hello is designed so that secrets never leave the secure environment (TPM/TEE). On hardware changes, old secrets are considered invalid, and the OS refuses to use them.
  • Lockscreen Failover Logic: If the primary credential (PIN) is unavailable and no password is set, the lockscreen enters a safety mode that blocks access rather than risking unauthorized entry.
  • Partial Admin Access Limitations: Many “PIN removal” commands only clear UI state or password accounts, but do not reinitialize the Ngc container or rebuild the credential provider metadata, leaving the system in an inconsistent state.

Real-World Impact

  • Business Continuity: Users are fully locked out of their devices immediately after hardware repairs or upgrades, causing downtime and potential data loss if BitLocker recovery isn’t available.
  • Support Escalation Costs: Tier-1 troubleshooting typically fails; devices often require reimage or an offline credential reset, increasing support load and user frustration.
  • Security vs Recoverability Trade-off: The strict hardware-binding security prevents attackers from transplanting disks to other machines, but it also makes legitimate recovery after component replacement hard without backups or recovery options.

Example or Code

  • Scenario: User upgrades motherboard, then runs net user username "" to remove password, but the Ngc folder remains and the PIN is still required, yet “no longer available.”
  • Safe resolution outline (pseudo-steps; exact code should be run with caution and admin rights): 
    rem Backup Ngc folder if possible before deletion
robocopy "%SystemRoot%\ServiceProfiles\LocalService\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Ngc" C:\NgcBackup /E /COPYALL /R:1 /W:1

rem Force Windows Hello to reset on next boot by clearing Ngc and re-enabling credential provider
takeown /f “%SystemRoot%\ServiceProfiles\LocalService\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Ngc” /r /d y
icacls “%SystemRoot%\ServiceProfiles\LocalService\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Ngc” /grant administrators:F /t
rmdir /s /q “%SystemRoot%\ServiceProfiles\LocalService\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Ngc”

rem Re-enable the Ngc service and credential provider states
reg delete “HKLM\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Authentication\Credential Providers{D6886603-1D4F-41F5-8D8A-A3F8C6B1C6AF}” /f
reg add “HKLM\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Authentication\Credential Providers{D6886603-1D4F-41F5-8D8A-A3F8C6B1C6AF}” /f

rem Reboot to trigger Windows Hello setup wizard on next login
shutdown /r /t 0

## How Senior Engineers Fix It
- **Use Offline Credential Reset:** If BitLocker recovery is available, use a recovery key to unlock the drive, then boot WinPE/WinRE and replace `utilman.exe` with `cmd.exe` to launch an admin command prompt at lockscreen, then create a new local admin and reset Windows Hello.
- **Clear Ngc Properly and Reinitialize:** Remove the Ngc folder and associated registry keys for Windows Hello, then reboot to force re-enrollment. Ensure the device is connected to the network and the user can re-add a PIN.
- **Fallback to Password First:** Re-enable password authentication via offline tools, log in, then disable PIN temporarily and reconfigure Windows Hello after verifying hardware identity is stable.
- **Reimage if Necessary:** If Ngc removal fails or encryption prevents access, a clean install or restore from backup is faster than manual repairs for non-expert users.

## Why Juniors Miss It
- **Confusing PIN with Password:** They think removing a password also removes PIN requirements; PIN is managed separately by the Windows Hello credential provider.
- **Assuming Files Are Enough:** Deleting the Ngc folder without registry cleanup or without forcing re-enrollment leaves the system expecting a PIN that no longer exists.
- **Ignoring Hardware Binding:** They don’t consider that hardware changes invalidate PIN secrets, so they don’t anticipate the “no longer available” state.
- **Lack of Offline Access Skills:** They don’t know how to use WinRE/WinPE or utilman replacement to gain access when the lockscreen blocks normal logon.