Issue getting the current user session from the server side (sveltekit – using appwrite for auth)

by

Summary

A SvelteKit server-side load function fails to retrieve the current user session from Appwrite because the session cookie name used for extraction does not match the cookie name actually stored by the Appwrite SDK. The client initialization in +page.server.js explicitly retrieves a cookie named a_session_<project_id>, whereas the createSessionClient helper in /server/appwrite.js retrieves a cookie named SESSION_COOKIE (likely a custom environment variable). Because event.cookies.get() cannot find the cookie with the mismatched name, the server detects no session, leading to authentication failures despite the client being logged in. Session retrieval logic is brittle when cookie names are hardcoded or mismatched across files.

Root Cause

The root cause is a cookie name mismatch between the frontend load function and the server-side authentication utility. This results in event.cookies.get() returning undefined, triggering the error logic intended for unauthenticated users.

Immediate technical causes:

  • Hardcoded cookie name: The +page.server.js file constructs the session name using PUBLIC_APPWRITE_PROJECTID directly: a_session_${PUBLIC_APPWRITE_PROJECTID.toLowerCase()}.
  • Inconsistent naming convention: The /server/appwrite.js file attempts to retrieve the cookie using SESSION_COOKIE, which is likely a constant defined elsewhere (e.g., .env variables) rather than the standard Appwrite session naming convention.
  • Implicit dependency on environment variables: The server logic relies on specific environment variables being correctly defined to match the SDK’s default behavior, which can drift if project settings change.

Why This Happens in Real Systems

Authentication issues often arise in server-side rendering (SSR) frameworks like SvelteKit due to how cookies are handled during the server-side render (SSR) pass versus client-side hydration.

Common architectural factors:

  • Server vs. Client State Mismatch: In SvelteKit, the load function runs on the server (during SSR) and potentially on the client (during navigation). If the server cannot read the cookie, it renders a “logged out” state, while the client might still have the session in memory.
  • Proxy/Reverse Proxy Configuration: If the application sits behind a proxy (like Nginx or Vercel’s edge), headers or cookies might be stripped or altered before reaching the Node.js runtime.
  • Third-Party SDK Abstractions: Using SDKs like Appwrite requires strictly adhering to their cookie naming schemes. Custom wrappers (like the createSessionClient function) can introduce subtle bugs if they abstract away the underlying cookie extraction logic incorrectly.

Real-World Impact

When this bug occurs, the user experience is severely degraded, often resulting in a “broken” feeling application.

Impacts include:

  • Authentication Loop: Users are logged in on the client but immediately redirected to a login page because the server renders an anonymous state.
  • Data Inconsistency: Protected data queries fail on the server, causing layouts to render empty states or throw errors (e.g., “No user session”).
  • SEO Issues: If the login state is required to view content, search engine crawlers (which execute server-side code) will see empty pages, hurting SEO rankings.
  • Developer Friction: Debugging is difficult because the network tab shows valid cookies, but the application logic fails, pointing developers toward network issues rather than logic errors.

Example or Code

The issue lies in the discrepancy between the two code snippets provided.

File: src/routes/+page.server.js

export async function load(event) {
  const { params } = event;
  const {id} = params;
  // Initialize a new Appwrite Client for the Server
  const { client } = createSessionClient(event);

  // 1. Extract the session cookie using STANDARD Appwrite naming
  const sessionName = `a_session_${PUBLIC_APPWRITE_PROJECTID.toLowerCase()}`;
  const hash = event.cookies.get(sessionName);

  // 2. Attach it to the client
  if (hash) {
    client.setSession(hash);
  }
  // ... rest of logic
}

File: /server/appwrite.js

export function createSessionClient(event) {
  const client = new Client()
    .setEndpoint(PUBLIC_APPWRITE_ENDPOINT)
    .setProject(PUBLIC_APPWRITE_PROJECTID);

  // 1. Extract the session cookie using CUSTOM/ENV naming
  // This line is likely the source of the error if SESSION_COOKIE 
  // does not match the Appwrite standard: 'a_session_'
  const session = event.cookies.get(SESSION_COOKIE);

  if (!session) {
    throw new Error('No user session');
  }

  client.setSession(session);

  return {
    get client() {
      return client;
    },
    get account() {
      return new Account(client);
    },
    get databases() {
      return new Databases(client);
    }
  };
}

How Senior Engineers Fix It

Senior engineers approach this by centralizing configuration and ensuring deterministic behavior across the stack.

Step-by-step remediation:

  1. Standardize Cookie Access: Remove the hardcoded string construction in +page.server.js. Instead, export the SESSION_COOKIE constant from /server/appwrite.js (or a shared config file) and import it into +page.server.js.
  2. Centralize Client Initialization: The load function should rely solely on createSessionClient to handle session extraction. Do not manually extract cookies in +page.server.js if the helper function already intends to do so.
    • Refactored logic: The load function should call createSessionClient(event). If the helper throws an error because the cookie is missing, handle that gracefully (e.g., return null data) rather than letting the app crash.
  3. Validate Cookie Settings: Ensure that SESSION_COOKIE matches exactly what Appwrite sets (usually a_session_<project_id_lowercase>). Also verify that the secure flag on cookies is set correctly for HTTPS environments (SvelteKit handles this via dev vs. production checks).
  4. Implement Error Boundaries: Wrap authentication calls in try/catch blocks within the load function to prevent the whole page from crashing if a session cookie is malformed.

Why Juniors Miss It

Junior developers often struggle to connect the dots between what the browser stores and what the server sees.

Common reasons for missing this:

  • Focus on Logic vs. Mechanics: Juniors often focus on the logic of the authentication (e.g., “Is the user logged in?”) rather than the mechanics of state transfer (cookies, headers, serialization).
  • Over-reliance on Copy-Paste: When integrating third-party SDKs (like Appwrite) with frameworks (like SvelteKit), developers often copy snippets from documentation or tutorials without fully understanding how the session cookie is named or passed.
  • Lack of Server-Side Debugging Skills: It is harder to inspect server-side state than client-side state. Juniors might check the browser’s Application tab to see that the cookie exists, but fail to log event.cookies.getAll() on the server to verify that SvelteKit is actually receiving the cookie.
  • Misunderstanding “Internal” vs. “External” Requests: Confusion often exists regarding which cookies are sent on internal SvelteKit navigation requests versus external API calls.