Is there an equivalent to F# Async.StartAsTask that returns Async and lets you pass in a cancellation token?

by

Summary

The question revolves around finding an equivalent to F# Async.StartAsTask that returns Async<‘T> and allows passing a cancellation token. This is necessary for canceling a child computation within an async computation expression without affecting the ambient token.

Root Cause

The root cause of this issue is the lack of a direct method in F# async that supports passing a cancellation token specifically for the child computation, similar to what StartAsTask offers when working with tasks. The key points are:

  • Async.StartAsTask allows for a cancellation token to be passed.
  • Async.StartChild does not directly support passing a cancellation token.
  • The current workaround involves converting the async operation to a task to utilize StartAsTask with a cancellation token.

Why This Happens in Real Systems

This happens in real systems because of the design differences between F# async and Task-based asynchronous programming. F# async is built around the concept of asynchronous workflows, which are designed to be composable and easy to use. However, certain features like explicit cancellation token support for child computations are more readily available in the Task-based model. The reasons include:

  • Design priorities in F# async focusing on composability and simplicity.
  • Task-based programming providing more low-level control over asynchronous operations.
  • The need for workarounds when F# async does not directly support a required feature.

Real-World Impact

The real-world impact of this limitation includes:

  • Increased complexity in code due to the need for workarounds.
  • Potential performance implications from converting between async and task-based operations.
  • Difficulty in managing cancellation tokens effectively in nested asynchronous computations.

Example or Code

let foo (token: CancellationToken) = 
    async {
        do! otherStuff
        try
            do! Async.StartAsTask(thingIWantToCancel, cancellationToken = token) |> Async.AwaitTask
            do! happyPath
        with
        | :? OperationCanceledException -> do! cleanupStuff
    }

How Senior Engineers Fix It

Senior engineers address this issue by:

  • Understanding the underlying design of F# async and Task-based programming.
  • Utilizing workarounds like converting to Task for operations that require explicit cancellation token support.
  • Implementing custom solutions or wrappers around Async.StartChild to support cancellation tokens if necessary.
  • Optimizing the code for performance and readability despite the workarounds.

Why Juniors Miss It

Juniors might miss this issue due to:

  • Lack of experience with the nuances of F# async and Task-based programming.
  • Insufficient understanding of cancellation token management in asynchronous computations.
  • Overlooking the implications of design differences between F# async and Task-based models.
  • Not recognizing the need for explicit cancellation token support in certain scenarios.