How to calculate magic constants for divide-by-multiply for constant modulo operation

by

Summary

The “divide by multiply” optimization is a technique used by compilers like clang to perform modulo operations more efficiently. This technique involves using a magic constant to multiply the dividend, resulting in a value that can be compared to another constant to determine the remainder. The goal is to calculate these magic constants reliably for a given prime number constant.

Root Cause

The root cause of the difficulty in calculating the magic constants lies in the mathematical properties of the divide by multiply algorithm. The algorithm relies on the fact that the product of the magic constant and the dividend is close to the product of the prime number constant and the quotient. The calculation of the magic constant involves finding a value that satisfies this property.

  • The prime number constant must be an odd number, which is a key constraint in the calculation.
  • The magic constant is typically a large negative number, which can be difficult to calculate directly.
  • The calculation of the magic constant involves a series of bitwise operations and multiplications, which can be error-prone if not implemented correctly.

Why This Happens in Real Systems

This issue occurs in real systems because the divide by multiply optimization is a common technique used in compilers to improve performance. The calculation of the magic constants is a critical step in this optimization, and any errors in this calculation can result in incorrect results.

  • Compilers like clang use this optimization to generate efficient code for modulo operations.
  • The magic constants are typically calculated at compile-time, and the resulting code is used to perform the modulo operation at runtime.
  • The prime number constant is often a parameter to the modulo operation, and the magic constants must be calculated for each possible value of this parameter.

Real-World Impact

The real-world impact of this issue is that incorrect calculation of the magic constants can result in incorrect results for modulo operations. This can have significant consequences in applications that rely on accurate modulo operations, such as:

  • Cryptographic algorithms that use modulo operations to perform encryption and decryption.
  • Numerical computations that rely on accurate modulo operations to perform calculations.
  • Embedded systems that use modulo operations to perform critical functions, such as control systems and signal processing.

Example or Code

struct DivMagic64 {
    int64_t magic;
    uint64_t cmpConst;
};

constexpr DivMagic64 computeDivMagic(uint64_t d) {
    assert(d >= 1 && (d & 1)); // only works for odd divisors
    const uint64_t cmpConstant = ~uint64_t(0) / d + 1;
    int64_t magic = -1 - (static_cast(cmpConstant) << 64) / d;
    return { magic, cmpConstant };
}

How Senior Engineers Fix It

Senior engineers fix this issue by using a combination of mathematical techniques and careful implementation to calculate the magic constants correctly. The key steps involve:

  • Using the prime number constant to calculate the cmpConstant.
  • Using the cmpConstant to calculate the magic constant.
  • Verifying the correctness of the magic constants through testing and validation.

Why Juniors Miss It

Juniors may miss this issue because it requires a deep understanding of the divide by multiply algorithm and the mathematical properties of the magic constants. Additionally, the calculation of the magic constants involves a series of bitwise operations and multiplications, which can be error-prone if not implemented correctly. Key takeaways for juniors include:

  • Understanding the key constraints of the prime number constant and the magic constants.
  • Carefully implementing the calculation of the magic constants using a combination of mathematical techniques and testing.
  • Verifying the correctness of the magic constants through thorough testing and validation.