Best installer strategy for Spring Boot app + Keycloak + MySQL + MongoDB on Windows?

by

Summary

The goal is to create a seamless installation experience for a complex backend stack consisting of Spring Boot, Keycloak, MySQL, and MongoDB on Windows. The installer must be designed to coexist with existing Java installations, detect and reuse existing database instances if possible, and configure services for non-technical users with minimal steps.

Root Cause

The complexity of the stack and the need for a user-friendly installation process without disrupting existing environments pose significant challenges. Key issues include:

  • Java version management to avoid conflicts
  • Database instance detection and configuration
  • Service registration for Keycloak and the Spring Boot application
  • User experience for non-technical users

Why This Happens in Real Systems

In real-world scenarios, complexity and compatibility are major concerns. Enterprises often have diverse software ecosystems, making it crucial for installers to be adaptive and non-intrusive. The combination of Spring Boot, Keycloak, MySQL, and MongoDB adds layers of complexity due to their different installation and configuration requirements.

Real-World Impact

The impact of a poorly designed installer can be significant, including:

  • System instability due to version conflicts
  • Data loss from incorrect database handling
  • Security vulnerabilities from misconfigured services
  • User frustration leading to support requests and potential abandonment of the software

Example or Code

# Example of installing and configuring MySQL on Windows silently
mysql_installer.exe --install --type=SERVER --port=3306 --servertype=SERVER --enable-services --rootpassword=password --defaults-file=C:\mysql\my.ini

How Senior Engineers Fix It

Senior engineers approach this challenge by:

  • Selecting the right installer tool that supports complex logic and silent installations (e.g., NSIS, Inno Setup, or Advanced Installer)
  • Implementing version checks for Java and databases to ensure compatibility
  • Developing scripts for automated configuration and service registration
  • Testing extensively for different scenarios and edge cases

Why Juniors Miss It

Junior engineers might overlook:

  • The importance of testing on diverse environments to ensure compatibility
  • Security implications of their configuration choices
  • The need for silent installation options for non-technical users
  • Version management to prevent conflicts with existing software installations