Why snackbar not showing anywhere

by

Summary

The snackbar is not appearing because the underlying navigation context is in an invalid state during the execution of the asynchronous userLogin method. When Get.snackbar is called, the GetIt/Get instance attempts to find a valid BuildContext (via Get.key.currentContext) to render the overlay. If the userLogin function completes or is triggered after a route has been removed (e.g., after Get.offAllNamed or during a widget rebuild), the current context is null. Additionally, there is evidence of a likely syntax error or infinite state loop within the provided code snippet that causes the controller or build method to throw, silently preventing the UI update.

Root Cause

  • Null Navigation Context: The Get.snackbar utility relies on Get.key.currentContext. In Flutter, overlays (like snackbars) require a valid NavigatorState attached to a widget tree. Asynchronous gaps (await) in controllers often lead to the context becoming invalid by the time the snackbar is triggered.
  • Silent Exception in Logic Flow: The provided code snippet ends abruptly with if (clientId.value != -1) { void o. This syntax error or incomplete statement likely causes the userLogin function to crash or fail to compile. If the error is caught in a generic catch block or ignored, the exception prevents the subsequent lines of code (including the snackbar call) from ever executing.
  • Race Condition with Route Replacement: If Get.offAllNamed(krHomeScreen) is called earlier in the flow than intended, it disposes of the previous route. Any subsequent attempt to show a snackbar on that route will fail.

Why This Happens in Real Systems

In Flutter development, context is finite. It exists only within the lifecycle of a widget in the widget tree.

  • Async Gaps: When you use await, the execution context can change. A user might navigate away, or a parent widget might rebuild and remove the subtree where the snackbar was intended to show.
  • Controller vs. View Separation: Business logic often resides in controllers (GetX/Observers). However, UI actions like showing a snackbar are strictly view-layer concerns. Calling view-layer logic from a controller after an async operation without checking the UI state is a common anti-pattern.
  • GetIt/GetX Overlay Issues: If Get.snackbar is called when Get.key.currentContext is null (often happening during app initialization or after a dispose event), the method returns false or throws an internal exception that is swallowed, resulting in zero user feedback.

Real-World Impact

  • Zero User Feedback: The user clicks “Login,” sees a loading spinner, and then the UI freezes or transitions without confirmation. The user does not know if the login succeeded or failed.
  • Debugging Blindness: Because the function fails silently (or the app crashes without a visible error if handled poorly), developers assume the code is running when it is actually deadlocked by an exception.
  • State Desynchronization: If the code crashes before saveBearerToken or saveUserId completes, the app enters a “half-logged-in” state where local storage is inconsistent with the backend.

Example or Code

The core issue is ensuring the context exists before calling the snackbar. A robust implementation checks the context and handles the async gap safely.

// A fixed version of the utility function that checks for context validity.
void showSnackBar({
  required String title,
  required String message,
  required Color color,
  int? duration,
}) {
  // Check if GetIt has a valid context (only works if using GetX overlays)
  // However, a more robust way is usually to pass the context explicitly
  // or use a GlobalKey.

  if (Get.key.currentContext == null) {
    print("Error: No valid context to show snackbar.");
    return;
  }

  Get.snackbar(
    title,
    message,
    backgroundColor: color,
    colorText: Colors.white, // cWhiteColor
    maxWidth: 400,
    duration: Duration(milliseconds: duration ?? 1500),
    snackPosition: SnackPosition.BOTTOM,
  );
}

How Senior Engineers Fix It

Senior engineers do not rely on implicit contexts in async flows. They implement the following patterns:

  1. Explicit Context Passing: Instead of calling a generic showSnackBar(), pass the BuildContext from the widget to the controller method. 
    Future userLogin(BuildContext context) async {
  // ... await logic ...
  if (response.success) {
    if (context.mounted) { // Check if widget is still in tree
      showSnackBar(...);
    }
  }
}
  2. Global Key for Navigation: In the main app layout, assign a GlobalKey<NavigatorState> to the MaterialApp. Inject this key into the service or controller. This allows navigation and overlay display from anywhere in the code without relying on the current context.
  3. State Machine Handling: Instead of scattering snackbars in the controller, emit a LoginSuccess or LoginError state event. The UI layer (Widget) listens to this state and triggers the UI feedback. This decouples logic from presentation.
  4. Syntax Validation: The immediate fix for the provided code is to resolve the syntax error (if (clientId.value != -1) { void o). Senior engineers ensure that code compiles and linters pass before investigating runtime logic.

Why Juniors Miss It

  • Assumption of Immediacy: Junior developers often assume that code executes linearly and instantly. They fail to account for await statements changing the execution environment.
  • Over-reliance on Global Helpers: Using Get.snackbar directly in controllers feels convenient, but hides the dependency on the widget tree. Without understanding the Flutter engine, it’s easy to assume these helpers “just work” everywhere.
  • Lack of Debugging Tools: When a snackbar fails to appear, juniors often look for UI code. They rarely check the console for the I/SurfaceControl (Android) or Flutter logs that might indicate a NullContext error or an uncaught exception earlier in the execution chain.
  • Ignoring Widget Lifecycle: They don’t realize that dispose() might have been called on the controller or view, rendering the context null.