Can python keywords be variables?

by

Summary

A developer encountered a limitation when attempting to use dynamic variable names as keyword arguments in a Python class constructor. The specific error was wanting to pass a string variable (e.g., "param1") as a keyword identifier inside **kwargs unpacking, which Python does not support in that syntax. This is a fundamental aspect of Python’s lexical analysis, not a bug or runtime limitation.

Root Cause

The root cause is a misunderstanding of unpacking syntax in Python. The ** operator requires a dictionary on the right-hand side, and the keys of that dictionary must be strings that are valid Python identifiers at the time of the call.

  1. Dictionary Literal vs. Variable: The syntax param1=setting1 inside a function call is syntactic sugar for {'param1': setting1}. The key param1 is defined as a literal string token.
  2. Key Restrictions: While Python dictionaries allow any hashable object as a key, function keyword arguments strictly require string keys.
  3. Variable Scope: The interpreter expects the keyword to be a literal name or a valid identifier. A variable holding a string (e.g., key = "param1") is not interpreted as a keyword definition; it is simply a value.

Why This Happens in Real Systems

This scenario frequently arises in meta-programming or API abstraction layers:

  • Dynamic Configuration: Systems reading settings from JSON/YAML files often need to map configuration keys to function arguments dynamically.
  • Proxy Objects: Middleware or decorators that forward arguments to underlying functions without knowing the specific signature in advance.
  • Refactoring: Legacy code where hard-coded keyword arguments are being migrated to dynamic data structures, but the developer attempts to mix syntax styles.

Real-World Impact

While the error is typically caught during development (syntax error or TypeError), the impact in a production environment includes:

  • Development Friction: Developers waste time debugging syntax that is fundamentally invalid rather than understanding the underlying mechanism of keyword arguments.
  • Design Rigidity: If the system relies heavily on hard-coded keyword arguments, it becomes difficult to extend functionality dynamically without rewriting code.
  • Performance Overhead: Inefficient workarounds (like exec or eval) might be introduced to force dynamic behavior where standard dictionaries should be used.

Example or Code

The following code demonstrates the error and the correct workaround.

class Test:
    def __init__(self, measurement, data, **kwargs):
        print(f"Measurement: {measurement}")
        print(f"Data: {data}")
        print(f"Kwargs: {kwargs}")

# Data setup
data = [1, 2, 3]
setting1 = "value1"
setting2 = 100

# 1. THE INCORRECT ATTEMPT
# This fails because Python expects a literal key name, not a variable.
try:
    key = "param1"
    # This raises a SyntaxError: cannot assign to literal
    # test_obj = Test('meas1', data, key=setting1) 
    pass
except SyntaxError as e:
    print(f"Syntax Error: {e}")

# 2. THE WORKAROUND (Dynamic Unpacking)
# Construct a dictionary first, then unpack it.
dynamic_params = {
    "param1": setting1,
    "param2": setting2,
    # dynamic keys can be built programmatically
    f"dynamic_{42}": "computed_value" 
}

# Unpack the dictionary using **
test_obj = Test('meas1', data, **dynamic_params)

# 3. ALTERNATIVE: Merging with existing kwargs
def complex_builder(**kwargs):
    # Injecting dynamic keys safely
    kwargs['injected_key'] = "injected_value"
    return Test('meas1', data, **kwargs)

complex_obj = complex_builder(param1=setting1)

How Senior Engineers Fix It

Senior engineers approach this by separating data from code execution. They avoid trying to trick the interpreter into treating variables as syntax.

  1. Use Dictionary Unpacking: Instead of trying to write dynamic keywords inline, they build a dictionary (often dict(), {}, or collections.ChainMap) containing the dynamic keys and values, then unpack it using **.
  2. Refactor Signatures: If a function requires massive dynamicism, the signature might be changed to accept a single configuration object or dictionary (e.g., config: Dict[str, Any]) rather than relying on **kwargs.
  3. Avoid exec/eval: Senior engineers strictly avoid using exec or eval to construct dynamic function calls, as this introduces severe security vulnerabilities (arbitrary code execution) and performance penalties.

Why Juniors Miss It

Junior developers often struggle with this distinction because:

  • Syntax Confusion: They may treat the = in a function call as a standard assignment operator (like in variable assignment), not understanding it is part of the argument syntax.
  • Learning Curve: The concept that **kwargs is essentially a dictionary (or vice versa) is not immediately obvious.
  • Desire for “Magic”: Juniors often look for clever one-liners to achieve dynamic behavior, overlooking the cleaner, more explicit pattern of building a dictionary and unpacking it.