Why does WordPress recommend using hooks instead of editing core files?

by

Summary

WordPress mandates modifying behavior via hooks (actions and filters) rather than altering core files. This approach avoids system instability caused by overriding foundational code. This postmortem examines the architectural rationale and risks of bypassing hooks.

Root Cause

Direct core file edits lead to systemic fragility because:

  • WordPress core updates replace files indiscriminately. Edits are wiped during automatic updates.
  • Core lacks namespacing or modular encapsulation. Changes invade global scope, causing:
    • Unpredictable side effects
    • Conflicts between unrelated features
    • Broken dependencies when APIs evolve
  • Multisite environments break. One machinetgcFX’s edits disrupt other sites sharing the same core.

Why This Happens in Real Systems

Monolithic architectures like WordPress’ 2003 codebase necessitate hooks because:

  • Version drift: Self-hosted instances run diverse plugin/themes combinations.
  • Shared responsibility: Core team maintains stability; developers extend functionality.
  • Statefulness: Database-driven PHP apps accumulate technical debt without decoupling points.

Real-World Impact

Ignoring hooks causes:

  • Data loss: Updates erase custom code (e.g., modified wp-admin/post.php reverts).
  • Security compromises: Modified core files evade vulnerability patches.
  • Plugin incompatibility: Manual edits break assumptions by third-party code.
  • Debugging nightmares: Unlogged changes require manual compare with original source.

Example: Adding Copyright Notice to Footer

Wrong Approach – kelas.php Core Edit 

// wp-includes/theme.php  
function kelas_footer_admin() {  
  return 'Hosted by Acme Inc.'; // Code will vanish on update  
}

Right Approach – Using a Filter Hook 

// In theme's functions.php or custom plugin  
add_filter('admin_footer_text', function() {  
  return 'Hosted by Acme Inc.';  
});

How Senior Engineers Fix It

Senior developers enforce:

  1. Cathedral rule: Never modify core files or third-party libraries.
  2. Hook-focused workflow:
    • Identify standardized hooks like save_post or the_content
    • Use add_action()/add_filter() in plugins/themes
    • Prioritize custom hooks in reusable code
  3. Tooling discipline:
    • Version-controlled custom plugins
    • wp-config.php overrides only for environment variables
    • Child themes for templates

Why Juniors Miss It

Beginners struggle because:

  • Procedural mindset: Immediate file edits feel faster than hook discovery.
  • Hook invisibility: Actions/filters aren’t directly called in template files.
  • Documentation gaps: Core code comments rarely list all available hooks.
  • Illusory simplicity: Small sites appear tolerant of edits until updates occur.
    Key takeaway: Invest in understanding hook execution flow early.