Should I log exceptions when raising or when catching?

by

Summary

When dealing with exceptions in programming, a common dilemma arises: where to log the exception. The two primary options are logging the exception when it is raised or when it is caught. Understanding the trade-offs between these approaches is crucial for effective error handling and logging.

Root Cause

The root cause of this dilemma stems from the desire to log exceptions in a way that provides the most context and follows good architectural practices. The key factors to consider include:

  • Context: Logging at the raise site can provide more detailed information about the error, such as the specific line of code that caused the issue.
  • Architecture: Logging at the catch site can be more architecturally sound, as it allows for a centralized error handling mechanism.

Why This Happens in Real Systems

In real-world systems, this dilemma occurs due to the following reasons:

  • Complexity: Large systems often have multiple layers, making it difficult to determine where to log exceptions.
  • Reusability: Code reuse can lead to exceptions being raised and caught in different parts of the system, making it challenging to decide on a logging strategy.
  • Scalability: As systems grow, the need for effective error handling and logging becomes more critical.

Real-World Impact

The impact of logging exceptions at the wrong place can be significant, including:

  • Information loss: Logging at the wrong place can result in losing valuable information about the error.
  • Debugging difficulties: Inadequate logging can make it challenging to debug issues, leading to increased downtime and development time.
  • Security risks: In some cases, logging sensitive information at the wrong place can introduce security risks.

Example or Code

try:
    # Code that may raise an exception
    x = 1 / 0
except ZeroDivisionError as e:
    # Logging at the catch site
    print(f"Caught exception: {e}")
    # Raising the exception again to propagate the error
    raise

How Senior Engineers Fix It

Senior engineers approach this dilemma by considering the following best practices:

  • Log at the catch site: This allows for a centralized error handling mechanism and provides a clear understanding of the error’s impact on the system.
  • Provide context: Include relevant information about the error, such as the exception message, stack trace, and any other pertinent details.
  • Use a logging framework: Utilize a logging framework to handle logging in a consistent and efficient manner.

Why Juniors Miss It

Junior engineers may miss the importance of logging exceptions at the right place due to:

  • Lack of experience: Limited experience with large, complex systems can make it difficult to understand the implications of logging exceptions.
  • Insufficient training: Inadequate training on error handling and logging best practices can lead to poor logging strategies.
  • Focus on functionality: Junior engineers may prioritize getting the code to work over implementing effective error handling and logging mechanisms.