Tkinter frame changes with buttons

by

Summary

The code attempted to implement a Tkinter frame change but failed due to incorrect function nesting and global state management. The frame_change function was never called because the ready_to_change flag logic was encapsulated in a nested function definition rather than being executed. Additionally, the window was misconfigured with a 1×1 pixel geometry, which made it invisible.

Root Cause

The primary cause was a logical error in defining the ready_to_change callback inside the welcome function. The code defined a nested function named ready_to_change instead of setting a boolean flag or calling the frame_change function directly.

  1. Invalid Function Definition: Inside welcome, ready_to_change was defined as a function that sets an outer variable ready_to_change to True. However, the variable ready_to_change at the line ready_to_change = False was likely intended as a flag, but the inner function shadowed it or failed to trigger the frame change logic.
  2. Missing Trigger: The welcome_end_button command is set to ready_to_change. When clicked, this executes the nested function, which sets a variable to True, but no code exists to check that variable and subsequently call frame_change.
  3. Global Variable Misuse: The occurence variable is used to trigger the initial welcome() call. However, the frame switching logic if ready_to_change(): is placed immediately after the call, checking the function object itself (which is truthy) rather than the result of an action.

Why This Happens in Real Systems

This pattern is common when developers mix imperative logic with event-driven architectures without fully understanding the execution flow.

  • Scope Confusion: Beginners often struggle with variable scope in Python. Defining a function inside another function creates a closure, but mutating a variable from the outer scope requires the nonlocal keyword (or modifying a mutable object like a list/dict).
  • Non-Blocking UI: GUI applications are event-driven. The mainloop runs continuously. The code structure implies a linear execution path (Welcome -> Click -> Menu), but the GUI requires explicit event bindings to jump between states.
  • Over-reliance on Global State: Using global variables (occurence, welcome_frame) to manage state makes the flow hard to track and prone to race conditions or stale data.

Real-World Impact

In a production environment, similar bugs lead to:

  • Application Freezes: If the UI thread enters an infinite loop waiting for a flag that never updates, the application becomes unresponsive.
  • Stale UI: Users might click buttons that trigger no action, leading to frustration and high support ticket volume.
  • Memory Leaks: While not severe in this specific snippet, improper frame management (creating new frames without destroying old ones) consumes memory over time.

Example or Code

The following is the corrected version of the logic. It replaces the flag-based approach with direct function calls and fixes the window geometry.

import tkinter as tk

def create_ui():
    window = tk.Tk()
    window.title("Dungeon RPG")
    # Corrected: Set a visible initial geometry (800x600) instead of 1x1
    window.geometry("800x600")

    color = "#304671"
    window.config(background=color)

    # Container for frames
    container = tk.Frame(window, bg=color)
    container.pack(fill="both", expand=True)

    # Define frames
    welcome_frame = tk.Frame(container, bg=color, bd=16)
    menu_frame = tk.Frame(container, bg=color, bd=16)

    def show_menu():
        # Hide welcome frame and show menu frame
        welcome_frame.pack_forget()
        menu_frame.pack(fill="both", expand=True)

    def show_welcome():
        # Hide menu frame and show welcome frame
        menu_frame.pack_forget()
        welcome_frame.pack(fill="both", expand=True)

    # Build Welcome Frame
    welcome_message_txt = "Welcome to Dungeon RPG"
    welcome_message = tk.Label(
        welcome_frame, 
        text=welcome_message_txt, 
        font=("Arial", 30), 
        bg=color, 
        fg="white"
    )
    welcome_message.pack(pady=20)

    # Direct command to switch frames
    welcome_btn = tk.Button(
        welcome_frame, 
        text="Continue", 
        font=("Arial", 20), 
        bg=color, 
        fg="white", 
        command=show_menu
    )
    welcome_btn.pack()

    # Build Menu Frame
    menu_label = tk.Label(
        menu_frame, 
        text="DungeonRPG - Main Menu", 
        font=('Arial', 35), 
        bg=color, 
        fg="white"
    )
    menu_label.pack(pady=20)

    # Back button to return to welcome
    back_btn = tk.Button(
        menu_frame,
        text="Back",
        font=("Arial", 20),
        bg=color,
        fg="white",
        command=show_welcome
    )
    back_btn.pack()

    # Start with welcome frame visible
    show_welcome()

    window.mainloop()

if __name__ == "__main__":
    create_ui()

How Senior Engineers Fix It

Senior engineers approach this by decoupling state management from the UI construction and adopting a MVC (Model-View-Controller) or State Machine pattern.

  1. Centralized State Management: Instead of scattered global variables, define a single ApplicationState class or dictionary. The UI updates solely based on the current state.
  2. Direct Function Binding: Buttons trigger specific, named state transition functions (e.g., go_to_menu()) rather than generic flags.
  3. Layout Management: Use a container frame and pack_forget() or grid_remove() to toggle visibility. This avoids the complexity of place() coordinates and ensures layout stability.
  4. Robust Initialization: Set a meaningful window size and ensure the window manager draws the window before the event loop starts.

Why Juniors Miss It

  • Procedural Mindset: Juniors often write code as if it were a script running top-to-bottom. They struggle to grasp that tkinter pauses execution at mainloop() and only runs code inside callbacks.
  • Scope Blindness: The concept that command=ready_to_change passes the function object itself, rather than executing it immediately or inspecting its internal logic, is a common stumbling block.
  • Debugging Difficulty: Visual bugs in GUIs are harder to debug than console output. If the window is 1×1 pixels, the application “works” (it runs), but the user sees nothing, making it hard to locate the logical error.